Avid readers of Professional Pensions may have seen an ariticle in the 6th September edition regarding the case of Waddy v Foster Wheeler (yes, THAT Foster Wheeler – just can’t seem to keep out of the pension press can it??). I was asked to comment on the case just as I was rising from a Magistrates’ court sitting so I’m not sure my thoughts were fully cogent at the time!!
The significance of this case is that it concerns the rights of gay couples in a Civil Partnership to the same pension rights as heterosexual spouses. Now you may have thought that all this was sorted some time ago with the passing of legislation back in 2005 and it’s reenactment under the Equality Act 2010. But the more techically minded amongst you will also remember that there was an option available to schemes to only “equalise” benefits which accrued post December 2005. And that’s what many schemes did of course – largely to control costs for which funding had not been provided prior to then.
It seems (although in fact aspects of this case have settled outside of court so there is no formal trancript of events) that Foster Wheeler did not provide full benefits for Civil Partners. Mr Waddy and his partner Mr Skipp had been together for 40 years and entered a CP in 2006. The scheme having taken advantage of the exception has now agreed to provide full benefits in this case but maintain that the scheme rules were entirely lawful.
Liberty who took the case on Mr Waddy’s behalf continue to maintain that the Equality Act exception is unlawful both in respect of EU law and under the European Convention of Human Rights. The point will be argued further in an Employment Tribunal in January 2012 and we await the outcome with interest.
I have to admit that even when the legislation was first passed, I did just wonder whether the temporal limitation would ever be challenged. Now it seems that it is, I suspect that if Liberty lose at the ET, that won’t be the end of the matter. It is amazing that in the second decade of the 21st Century we should still be in doubt as to the intent and validity of equal rights. But that’s pensions for you. Why make things simple when it’s so much fun to make it complicated…
Jennie advises large multi-employer schemes as well as smaller single employer arrangements and has wide experience of both Defined Contribution and Defined Benefit schemes. Jennie qualified in 1986 originally as a criminal prosecutor. She sits as a Magistrate in her local justice area and is an Approved Chairman and Deputy Chair of the Bench Training and Development Committee. Jennie was formerly Legal Director of the Occupational Pensions Regulatory Authority. When her busy practice allows, Jennie likes to indulge her passion for travelling. To consult Jennie on any corporate Pensions matter, please call her on +44 (0)20 7749 2700 or send her an email by clicking below: